Sunday, 4 July 2010

The Harry Potter Readathon

Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone

image

 

This boy will be famous. There won't be a child in our world that won't know his name. There will be books about him, he will be a legend.'

Minerva McGonagall.

 

 

Along with Becky from Escapism Through Books I am re-reading the Harry Potter books from start until finish. She’ll probably finish way before me though, as I’m a slow poke. I’ve just finished The Philosopher’s Stone and about to move onto the second one – well I will when I finish this blog post.

I have not read these books since the Deathly Hallows came out and how long ago was that? Long enough to be without Harry Potter and to think I used to read this series at least once every year – when I was younger even more, over and over and over and over again. I was a Harry Potter child – I grew up with him ever since I read the first book back in 1998 when I’d have been 12 or 13. Ever since then I waited for the next book to come out each time feeling that rush of pure happiness every time I opened up another Harry Potter book for the first time.

Of course, now that is all over – I know what happens at the end, I know the fates and fortunes of all the characters. I remember each time I finished one that I’d be dying to read the next immediately after – between books three and four there had only been a year’s wait but the three year gap that it took her to write The Order of the Phoenix was probably the longest three years in my life. To make it short – just like the millions of others out there I absolutely adored Harry Potter and I still do.

The only difference now is that I feel a little emotional reading it for the first time – from beginning to end whilst knowing the whole story. Ten years is a huge chunk of your life especially starting from that sort of age – these books feel like a part of me, I’ve turned the pages so many times through so many different ages. I’ve seen Harry grow up, I’ve got to know him and his friends and fallen in love with Ron many, many a time.

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone started it all. It isn’t really the most exciting books in the series – but it’s the very first one and it has something special – because the first moment I read it, I knew, I just knew I had something special. I hadn’t been at all aware of all the hype at the time, my dad had bought it for himself to read and then I inherited it off him. I wanted mainly to know why an old codger like my dad would be doing reading a kid’s book. So I never had any expectations about it – it was just a book.

I don’t really know what to say about this. I have never actually reviewed Harry Potter, it’s just such a part of myself that I can’t express it.

I wonder if I’d have enjoyed them had I not read them when I did – had I let the hype effect me. Would have have gone in thinking the book was going to be spectacular and then been unimpressed? Would the hype have turned me off? Perhaps now it would have – I’m not too sure. I’d probably have been so fed up with hearing ‘Harry Potter this’ and ‘Harry Potter that’ along with the whole Hollywood machine. Publishers have also I think started to pay YA books a lot more attention since Harry Potter, knowing they can turn it into a great money spinning machine. I’d probably have been put off by that and maybe more influenced by any negative reviews. Maybe, I don’t know. I don’t think it would have been the same had I not started them as a child, barely even a teenager.

I think what makes Harry Potter magical is that it is a world you can believe in – you can imagine getting an invitation to Hogwarts. It is criticised for not being unique enough – but then what is? It isn’t the individual parts that make it good – but it as a whole. Every generation of children need something like Harry Potter – Narnia is too dated and Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings trilogy is a little too heavy for younger children. Harry Potter is unique – in that it captures the imagination of children in ways not many other books have done before especially not so much in recent years.

It covers many familiar themes – good vs evil, love vs. hate, death vs. life, friendship vs. enemies. I think within Harry Potter, hopefully picked up by it’s young readers are lessons about love and acceptance of others despite their differences. That death is not a bad thing – as Dumbledore himself said it is the next great adventure – but the fear of death, or not being allowed to die is in fact, much much worse. It teaches you the love of life – loyalty of friendship, standing up for what is right and good – and fighting against bigotry. Which is why I have little time for all that mumbo jumbo about how Harry Potter is full of evil witch craft and is potentially harming your children by teaching them a load of hocus pocus. If those bigots actually read Harry Potter they might actually learn a couple of things.

Well, that’s a rant I don’t really want to get into. Not liking Harry Potter is one thing and personal opinion, campaigning that it’s devilry, full of Satan worshipping and whatever other rubbish is aimed at it is another thing altogether.

I think the strength of Harry Potter lies in its familiarity. Wizard school, robes, wands, potions – all those kinds of clichés that others might try to avoid are used by JKR to create a world that feels like it already exists. I think personally, the best, most magical books are the ones that feel like you already know that world exists. It pops into your imagination so quickly and so smoothly, but yet it different to anything else you have ever read before. It becomes so real that not believing in it becomes difficult. I think even the most inane things about Harry Potter would become immediately interesting. It all comes down to the small little details – the histories, the magical items and things and just wanting it to be real.

It’s amazing to think that Harry Potter really does exist in millions of people’s imaginations. That the people who initially started reading them as children might have children of their own by now. That it was enjoyed not just by the children, but by the parents, children and grandparents as well and so for once – children got to actually share a book with their parents on a completely equal level of enjoyment – not just a children’s book the parents read with the child – perhaps enjoy but not quite so much. For ten years he existed in everyone’s hopes and dreams – in their joint imaginations. Young people read Harry Potter over and over again and pored over pages for clues about what would happen next. They analysed it, wrote essays about it – read it over and over.

It might not be your typical literary novel that you dissect in English class – but you know it got children reading and not just reading – but analysing a book on their own, not because they had to in school – usually some book that could have been interesting had you not had to write fifty essays about the same mundane thing. Harry Potter got people reading between the lines and talking. When, since The Lord of the Rings came out, has that ever happened?

I realise now I am rambling. I could never write a review for Harry Potter – I don’t know if I’ll be able to. It’s too difficult – Harry Potter isn’t just a series of books to me it’s part of my make-up, it’s what makes me love reading. It’s that feeling of being in love with a book, lost in a book, being so, so, so happy just being able to read them and feel that feeling again no matter how often I read them.

These books are my friends, they live in my heart and just thinking about it all makes me quite emotional. When I speak of Harry Potter though, I can’t speak of it just by looking at one book individually, but as a whole. I may try to write some sort or review, maybe a review of feelings then anything else – but I can’t say what is good and bad about each individual book and treat them in such a way. Just like I can’t read one book without reading all the others one after the other. I can’t just re-read the first book then wait a bit and read the second some weeks down the line. I have to read it now and carry on until I get to the end.

I have probably succeeded in repeating myself several times and making little sense. Anyway, I’m on a Harry Potter readathon and I’ve been wanting to do this for a long time. So goodbye for now – and Happy Independence day to all you Americans over across the pond.

Saturday, 3 July 2010

Magic Kingdom – Terry Brooks

image

star1 star1star1star1

 Genre: Fantasy
Published: 1986
Pages: 373

 

Ben Holiday, a high flying Chicago lawyer is fed up with his life decides to jump ship and buy a fantasy kingdom called Landover. Only he got a little bit more then he bargained for. This is the first book in the Landover series.

It took me a little while to get into this book to be honest with you, not so much because of the book but due to my mood and personal things that happened at the time I started it. However, for the most part I enjoyed it and think I would have enjoyed it a lot more had it not been for the exact time I started reading it. I wavered between giving it 3.5 or 4 stars but decided, because the ending was pretty good that I’d round it up. It’s the first book in a while I’ve felt I have really enjoyed.

It reminded me slightly of one of those old pixelated point and click games like Simon the Sorcerer where you click on ‘pick up’ or ‘use’ from the command menu – or maybe even more like the really old King’s Quest type games where you had to write ‘look’ or ‘pick up’ which I used to love playing. In fact, it’s made me really want to play Simon the Sorcerer again as I never completed it as a kid but I did used to love it. Hmm wonder if it’d work on Vista? (Damn you Microsoft!) Anyway that isn’t really anything to do with this review at all.

Brooks’ writing could occasionally be a little repetitive – he liked the word admonished quite a bit and Ben was forever wanting to throttle people and the characters were slightly flat and predictable. However, the story was the strongest point and there were quite a few times when I laughed out loud. The world was quite imaginative in a clichéd way  – it’s your typical ‘fantasy’ land complete with dragons, witches, wizards and other fairy people as it said in the sales pitch. It felt a little undeveloped as a whole but it is the first book in a series so I think the set up will lead on to something stronger. I loved the castle Sterling Silver being a ‘living’ thing and I also really thought the idea of the ‘fairy’ world was incredibly interesting – I hope in the following books we get to go back there.

The following book ‘The Black Unicorn’ sounds good already – but seeing as I’m on this book ban for the foreseeable future and have a huge stack of library books I haven’t read yet (bugger that’s just reminded me I have an overdue loan!!) I am not sure when I’ll get to it. I have a feeling these are light easy book that can be easily dipped in and out of. I’m not gasping to read the second one but I know that I want to. It’s on the post-ban wish-list.

Friday, 2 July 2010

Trendy Reading

I might have mentioned in the past my spreadsheet. Before I joined Goodreads.com I used to keep a written record of all the books I read and owned. Obviously this wasn’t really the best of records – my hand writing is illegible and my TBR list was a mess. For a while I got a bit fed up of doing it and then I discovered Goodreads so I transferred my written records over onto there and I think that’s when my obsession started. I loved having a record of all the books I have read, own and want to read.

However Goodreads didn’t do everything I wanted it to at the time so at the start of 2009 I created a spreadsheet in Microsoft Excel. Here it is:

spreadsheetscreenshot

It’s become a ritual every time I start a new book I have to enter the book number, the title, the author, year of publication, number of pages, setting, genre, whether it is a library book, from my TBR or otherwise and then date started. As I read it I record how many pages I read every day on a different sheet. When I finish the book I mark date finished and how many days it took to read. Then I update my monthly book count – how many books I read in a month and total number of pages in a month. Am I admitting slightly too much here, is my obsessiveness slightly on the weird side, I wonder? Maybe it’s best I keep in the closet but I happen to quite love my spreadsheet. It’s definitely very useful for looking back and seeing my year objectively and visually.

2009 setting This is a pie chart showing the settings of the books I read in 2009. As you can see 43% of the books I read were set in England, the second largest being the USA at 14%. This makes me think that I am not very daring in my book choices, not moving very far from home or familiar culture and still I seem to be sticking mainly to British settings then any other. In fact not even British – just England. I haven’t read anything from Scotland, Wales or North Ireland this year or last at all.

Looking at the books I have been reading recently nothing much has changed – England is still my biggest setting. I’ve always wanted to be an adventurous reader – I’ve always thought I read quite a broad range of books but looking at this I’m thinking that maybe, I don’t.

Why is this? Is it because I don’t want to move out of my comfort zone? Am I not interested in different cultures, different histories, different politics?

How many of these books are actually translated works – not just set in these countries? Only 7 books out of the 48 books I read in 2009 were translated from a different language – these were from the countries of Sweden (3), Chile (1), Iran (1) and Japan (2). That is really abysmal. I don’t think I’m a very eclectic read at all.

I’m planning of course to read more Japanese literature this year – maybe my 2010 pie chart will improve somewhat and Japan will get a larger slice.

I do have a fair amount of translated works in my TBR, although they aren’t a large proportion by any rate. If anything they consist mostly of Dostoyevsky and Murakami.

I suppose having over half my total reads as international isn’t quite the worst thing, after all there’s nothing wrong with reading books set in my own country. I wouldn’t say when buying or looking for a new book I pay much attention as to where it is set, I am rather more interested in the story. Maybe subconsciously though I am finding books with an English setting more interesting then any other. Maybe it is just how bookshops organise their sales so it is these books I come into contact with more.

I wonder how this compares with people who are from a non-English speaking country? I’m only imagining that more English-language books are available to other countries then vice versa. I don’t go out looking for foreign, translated fiction on purpose so if it comes by me then it’s usually by chance. Most books I see around me seem to be English language books. I’m presuming that there’s a lot of books out there that I will never get to read because I can’t speak any other language other then English.

And this brings me to Genre – yes I made another pie chart.

2009 genre

In 2009 it is quite evident that Historical and Crime were my two main genres. Before last year I hadn’t read many of either these two genres so I am quite pleased about this. Novel should really be ‘General Fiction’.

I split the YA up into specific genres as well as it is unfair in my opinion to just lump all YA into only one genre for this purpose anyway. However only 16% of books I read last year were for young adults. In 2007/8 I’d say about 60% would have consisted of YA books of numerous genres.

What genres have I missed out on I wonder, what could I improve on? How will 2010 be shaped genre-wise?

This year the historical novel is still quite popular and I’ve had a fairly long spree of fantasy lately. I keep saying to myself ‘read more classics’ so who knows what my 2010 pie chart will look like?

Has anyone else made a pie chart of their readings? I’m quite obsessive about keeping a log of the books I read. I even have a spreadsheet that I record all my books read, pages read etc etc etc. I’m hoping the answer will be yes, of course so I’m not alone.

On average, I read four books a month (technically 3.8) in 2009 as I’m a slow poke when it comes to reading – I read one book at a time so I can give each book my individual attention. The only books I do piggy back are non-fictions. My average page count a month is 1605.

This year my average is currently standing at 4.5 books per month and 1622 pages so not really seeing any dramatic improvements or changes there.

I really want to be more adventurous in my reading – looking at this I don’t think I am. I should read more lesser known authors and take chance I wouldn’t normally take. Maybe in 2011 I should challenge myself not to read books set in the UK. I should actually take part in more book challenges and take control over what books I read, not allow the wind to blow me from one book to the other.

The trouble is I said this all to myself at the end of 2009 and here I am still faffing around with the same old books, same old genres, same old settings. In six months we shall see if any of this changes. I’m looking forward to seeing my 2010 pie charts.

Weekly Geeks – Andrew Taylor

The theme for Weekly Geeks this week is to:

A. Write a letter of appreciation to a new to you author whose work you have read and was really impressed with.

Or

B. Write a letter to a firm favourite author of yours, preferably someone alive – letting them know how much you either admire or even love their work.

I’m choosing option B. and am going to write a letter to Andrew Taylor, my favourite crime writer. I must admit… I’m rather too shy to actually send him one. Oh… I know I should. Maybe it’s a bit rude to write him one here, share it with everyone else and then not actually let him read it!

Anyway, for those of you who don’t know him, which may be many as he though highly respected, doesn’t seem to be popular. Andrew Taylor is a British mystery author who writes mostly books set in the past. He has won several awards from the Crime Writer’s Association (CWA) including the Diamond Cartier Dagger in 2009 for sustained excellence in crime writing.

I recommend:

- The American Boy/An Unpardonable Crime (US title)

- The Four Last Things (first in the Roth trilogy)

- An Air that Kills (first in the magnificent Lydmouth series)

Anyway, now you’re all a little acquainted with each other let me begin…

Dear Andrew Taylor,

I would like to say thank you for writing so many excellent books that I have really, really enjoyed reading. You were one of my first crime writers and I’m really starting to enjoy this genre too. My first book was The Four Last Things – after watching Fallen Angel on the telly and since then I’ve gone on to read loads more. I loved The American Boy and An Air that Kills. I’ve since passed them onto my crime-loving-mother and she has become a big fan of yours too.

I really love the way you write – you always make me feel as if I’m there in those pages, the characters feel real and the settings are so vivid and atmospheric. I just love being lost in a book and you’ve never failed me in this. I haven’t read all of your books yet because I like having the sense that I still have some yet to read so I’m holding out on a few.

I can’t wait until The Anatomy of Ghosts comes out in September, good luck for when it comes out I’m sure you’ll be really busy.

Thanks so much for writing my favourite books in the world.

Best Wishes

Fiona

Kind regards? Yours Sincerely? Love? what do you put when writing to a random stranger you happen to really admire? This is why I can’t actually send the letter, I’d feel too much like a complete and utter berk. There’s so much more I want to say but I don’t want to come across as a fanatical lunatic blubbering about how I would read everything he writes, even his shopping list. I don’t want him to read my letter and think “what a complete idiot, I can’t believe she reads my books!” I know, I know I’m being paranoid (probably?)

I’m getting butterflies even thinking about sending him a letter like this. I know, I’m a coward most likely he’d appreciate it but sometimes I’m just happier feeling like an anonymous fan.

Thursday, 1 July 2010

Booking Through Thursday – Disappointment

btt button

Name a book or author that you truly wanted to love but left you disappointed. (And, of course, explain why.)

The Summer Garden by Paulina Simons is the third and last in the Tatianna and Alexander trilogy.

I loved The Bronze Horseman and I liked Tatiana and Alexander. Simons originally intended to end it with the second book – this is fairly obvious from the epilogue. However she decided to milk her most popular book again by writing a third book. Disappointment is not really the word to describe how I felt. I was so excited that there was going to be a third, despite thinking the second one was probably a good place to end. I just wanted to get back into these characters again.

Well – let me say – she turned two good characters into two people I loathed. She butchers them – I don’t mean literally. It is quite possibly the worst book that I have ever read – I didn’t even get to finish reading it because I just couldn’t read another 300 pages of them doing the exact same thing, just hacking away at the exact same storyline and not really taking it anywhere else.

Simons wanted to show what happened to them afterwards and how they coped and survived through what happened to them in the previous books. Which is all very well if she dealt with it logically but she didn’t at all. The characters did nothing but argue, have sex and move around the country for at least the first half.

I fell in love with The Bronze Horseman – it’s a really good book and I would recommend it completely and honestly – even the sequel Tatianna and Alexander. I would not, on any account recommend the third. In fact – this might sound slightly very arrogant of me – but I would probably recommend giving it a wide birth.

It has a rather high average rating on Amazon and on Goodreads – but considering only 22 people on Amazon.com and only 18 people on Amazon.co.uk actually bothered reviewing it – compared to the 183 people and 100 who reviewed The Bronze Horseman – I can presume that many people were so disappointed that they were not even able to get so far as reviewing it.

I suppose I shouldn’t really have been too surprised – I read Simons’ The Girl in Times Square as well – which I did actually finish – and that was pretty abysmal too. I guess Simons has for me – reached the end of the road. I really enjoyed Tully as well – another book I would quite openly recommend – but I don’t think I can enjoy this author any more. These last two books I have read by her weren’t just merely boring, they were just systematically atrocious – almost like reading a car crash.

So in answer to that question – apologies for going off on one – Paulina Simons left me feeling massively disappointed because I really thought I loved her and then she wrote those two suckers. Talk about falling from cloud #9 to ground floor zero.

Character Connection – Mary Lennox

character connection Character Connection is hosted by IntrovertedJen over at The Introverted Reader every Thursday.

We all have characters we love. Let's spotlight these fantastic creations! Whether you want to be friends with them or you have a full-blown crush on them, you know you love them and want everyone else to love them too!

Today my character is Mary Lennox from The Secret Garden. (Spoilers ahead, beware!)

What I love so much about Mary as a character is that she evolves, she changes from a troubled young girl, to a mature and kind young person. Characters who change for the better have always interested me as a reader, because I think it shows that you can improve upon yourself.

Someone like Mary, who at first came across as a surly, selfish individual shows that you have to look a bit further and see that there might be a really good, kind person underneath. Mary discovered friendship and what it is to be a human – to have feelings and to be loved. When she found The Secret Garden she wanted to bring it back to life, to make it grow.

Martha, the maid showed her kindness and treated her like a child – she discovered friendship with Martha’s brother Dickon and learnt about wildlife and nature. She even befriended the rather grump gardener.

And then she met her cousin Colin, an invalid who abandoned my his father when his mother died, has been brought up bed ridden and alone, without companionship of anyone his age – until Mary discovers him. By the time Mary finds Colin, Mary has already undergone slight transformations of her own. She understands Colin – probably better then he does. She is the only one stubborn enough not to put up with his invalidism and eventually persuades him that he can get out of bed and go outside.

Through Mary, Colin also finds friendship and a new sense of life and living. Through Mary an overgrown, abandoned garden once again finds life to grow – through Mary a lot changes at Misselthwaite Manor. Through Mary – a father learns not to be afraid of love again and comes home to stay. Misselthwaite is no longer a grey, abandoned building with a wailing child and tangled garden.

It’s rather a simple story about inner change, symbolised through the revival of a long forgotten garden – but I think the changes that happen to each of the characters – Mary, Colin and Colin’s father are incredibly significant and powerful. There’s a strong moral message that runs throughout the story – the healing power of love and acceptance that the author Frances Hodgson Burnett weaves into the story without making it sickly sweet, or hammering her morals into the reader in a way that could be patronising.

I love Mary’s character because of her personal growth. I also, as I have mentioned in my earlier character connection blog posts – would love to know what happened to her afterwards? I think they made a film of an imagined sequel but I have never seen it – or interested to. It’s so much more fun imagining for myself what will happen afterwards.

Will she maintain her friendship with Dickon as she grows up into a young lady? I would imagine her uncle would treat her equally as a child of his own and she would become quite a wealthy young woman so it might be difficult maintaining that kind of friendship. It is a romantic thought to think that social class differences wouldn’t matter. They would travel in different circles and different things would be expected of them. They might remain on good friendly terms, maybe even keeping in contact with each other – but not as close friends beyond childhood.

She might be sent to a school – so might Colin. Would they be sent to boarding school? I think not – Colin’s father wouldn’t be so eager to send them away from him so soon. Would they remain at Misselthwaite however? Maybe the garden was an important part of their childhood, their lives and their healing process – but after a while it would have served its purpose and as children they would have moved on to different paths.

Colin and Mary would remain close friends and travel in the same circles. I don’t think they would ever be more then friends – I can’t remember if it was just in the 1993 film that it was suggested that Colin wanted more then friendship – but personally if this was the case they were only children and things rarely stay the same from when you are ten to when you are an adult. I wonder if they would eventually fall out – I imagine Mary would still maintain a slightly stubborn streak and they both might want to go in different directions.

Colin I imagine would want to travel – being stuck in bed for so long would give anyone the desire to see the world you missed for a good part of your childhood. Mary I’m not so sure what she would do to be honest – maybe should would rather stay at Misselthwaite manor. Maybe Colin would marry but wouldn’t want to go back there.  Perhaps Mary would become it’s mistress after a time, or maybe she would move elsewhere and the old house would be closed up as it doesn’t really seem like the kind of place for a young lady to live – she would never meet anyone else. Plus old country houses in England were becoming less popular and too expensive to run – they weren’t quite so fashionable as they were in the past.

I do not think Mary will become on of those frivolous young ladies who only care about society and all that – her parents were forever going to parties and balls and I think she would not want to lead that kind of careless life. Not that she wouldn’t enjoy them, I think they would not become the main focus of her life. If she has children she will love them and care for them – one would hope that your own experiences would teach you to be different with your own children. Not always but in Mary’s case I think she would.

Of course – The Secret Garden was published in 1910/11 so by the time Mary is about fourteen the first world war would start and eighteen when it ends. How old was Dickon by that time he might have been old enough to enlist. Perhaps Dickon would become a world war one casualty – or if he survives a damaged war hero. Many of Misselthwaite’s other serving staff would have also left to join the war or to do other war work so things would have changed for Mary quite quickly.

By the second world war Mary would be 38 – what would she be like then? Would she have a husband in the war – maybe even a son just old enough to go into the war if she married and had children early. What of her life then? It must have been hard for people during those times, who were old enough to remember both wars – to live through one during your youth, perhaps losing brothers to it – and then see your own children become part of the second one.

Misselthwaite might have been requisitioned by the army during the second world war – it would have been transformed into a completely different place. If she was still living there she would have had to move out or at least into a different wing maybe. Would she still be tending her garden? Would she be able to boss the old colonel around like her old Ayah?

According to Wikipedia:

The final blow for many country houses came following World War II; having been requisitioned during the war, they were returned to the owners in poor repair. Many of whom having lost their heirs, if not in the immediately preceding war then in World War I, were now paying far higher rates of tax, and agricultural incomes from the accompanying estates had dropped. Thus, the solution appeared to be to hold contents auctions and then demolish the house and sell its stone, fireplaces, and panelling. And this is exactly what happened to many of Britain's finest houses. – Wiki

It is a terrible thought to think of all the beautiful country houses England must have lost during this time. Of course, now we look back and see them as relics of history – back then they were seen as more functional and family based rather then historic interest – perhaps. Was Misselthwaite to suffer this ending? It would be sad to think so. Maybe Misselthwaite, being in the middle of practically nowhere though, would not be wanted by the army. Who knows. When Burnett wrote The Secret Garden the first world war had not yet started, such dark shadows would never have crossed Burnett’s mind whilst writing the book. In her imagination, maybe they all lived happily ever after.

Wednesday, 30 June 2010

Review Ratings

newowlchart

I read an interesting blog entry over at Shannon Hale’s blog about ratings for books which got me thinking about how I choose my rating. Mostly it got me thinking about whether I should give it any kind of numeric rating at all and just leave it to the review.

Hale asked some questions at the end and even though the post is a bit old, I thought seeing as I’m a fairly new blog, just leaving its nest I though I’d answer them.

1. Do you find that the anticipation of reviewing the book has changed your reading experience?

It makes me be a less passive reader. Before I joined Goodreads I always used to keep a hand written log of books I read – I gave them a star rating and a short review – usually a few lines. Now, since joining Goodreads I promised myself to review every book I read – more then a paragraph. Knowing others would be reading them I put more effort into them.

Reviewing a book is part of the reading process for me, it helps me to digest a book and I think it is very important to do so. Otherwise I am just reading it and then what happens to the book? It disappears to the back of my memory. That’s why I started making a log of books in the first place because it meant that I would remember each book I read. After a few years, looking back through it, even though much was illegible scrawl it really helped because I could see that – yes I liked that book and I could read what I liked about that book. There were my initial thoughts written down straight after finishing and it is that little bit of a memory I might have otherwise forgotten.

Writing reviews for Goodreads though, and now this blog has made me a more active reader – I am thinking about what I would like to mention in my review as I read, I am trying to notice more things and digest my feelings. I want to be involved in my reading, in the books that I read. It greatly effects how I read.


2. Are you rating the book even as you read? Or do you wait until the end to sum it all up?

I usually do have a rating playing at the back of my mind, maybe this does distract me from reading it if I’m constantly thinking about how good it is (or isn’t)? I think it is harder to simply enjoy a book now because I feel that I have to justify it afterwards.


3. Does knowing you'll be reviewing it (or rating it) publicly affect which books you pick up in the first place?

Hmm, yes and no. I don’t choose not to read a book because I don’t want to review it, or because I want to review it in particular, but being more involved in the books I am reading does make me want to read different kinds of books and makes me less patient with certain types of fiction I might have read before I started reviewing. I like more involving books in the recent years.

Thinking more about it, looking back I have picked up less dud books – maybe this is from reading reviews and also, maybe it is because I just enjoy books more now because I put more effort into reading them.


4. Does the process of writing the review itself change how you felt about the book?

I don’t think so. It does make me reflect more, but I wouldn’t say it changes how I felt. Reading other people’s reviews might change how I feel – especially if they noticed something I did not which may change my entire outlook on the book.


5. What is your motivation to assign a rating to a book and declare it to the world?

I have always assigned a rating even before I declared it to the world. I find other people’s ratings of interest and use myself and now that I’m ‘declaring it to the world’ I feel like I’m a much more active reader. Reading isn’t about locking yourself away in a dark room with a light – it’s as social as many other past times and it is good to be able to share your experiences and opinions with others.

I don’t think that ratings are on their own useful, which makes me wonder if I should use a numerical rating on this blog? On websites like Amazon and Goodreads it is much easier to put the ratings together as a whole – and see your friends’ ratings alongside each other.

On a personal level, a numerical rating gives me closure and I like looking back some years later and seeing how much I liked it. A rating is like a place mat in my memory.

Are numerical ratings on blogs as useful as they might be on Amazon or websites like Goodreads?


6. If you review a book but don't rate, why not? What do you feel is your role as reviewer?

My role as a reviewer – difficult one. Am I a reviewer? I consider myself more a reader then a reviewer. I just happen to write a review afterwards. chocolate chop Reviews are more important then ratings. Everyone will have different ideas on the value of each star and the meaning. I explain what mine mean here.

I have always found it difficult whether to rate between how much I enjoyed a book and literary merit. Should I detract a star because I thought it was badly written in parts even though I really enjoyed it or should I not? Bad, irritating clumsy writing does bother me but I can look over it depending on other factors.

I personally love really good characters and so I lean more towards more character driven books then anything else.

Writing this entry makes me think of a much more simpler question to ask myself:

Why do I read?

  • Entertainment?
  • Escapism?
  • To learn something different?
  • Intellectualism?

I think it is a mix of all of these – but mostly because I find reading entertaining. The days of required reading are over – I choose what books I read to simply enjoy them. I read so I can be taken out of my world and taken into another one – into a life I don’t know about to learn about them. Books can take you back, and forwards through time – they also help you understand different people and put you in someone else’s shoes so you can share their experiences – and not be confined to your own. You can learn so much from reading books – I mean fiction, not just non-fiction.

I do not read a book simply for its literary worth – that isn’t to say of course, that I’m not able to appreciate it. So overall, I think I rate on how much I enjoyed a book rather then trying to define it by its literary merits.

I still find it hard to rate though – it’s so very subjective and sometimes it just doesn’t reflect at all how I felt. Sometimes I want to change the rating of a previous review because of a more recent one. Should ratings stick once you’ve made them – at the moment I’ve been reading a lot of fantasy and so they are comparing to each other in my head. I find my scales are being readjusted in my head. Maybe I need to award more then five stars or will that make it harder still?

How does everyone else rate? What kind of a scale do you use and what does each actually mean to you? What do you look for in reviews and how does the rating affect you?

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails